Progress must lead to permanent change

A historic social victory marks a stepping stone towards future progress


Leah Allen '22

The verdict in the trial of former police officer Mr. Derek Chauvin April 20 is only the first step in a long journey towards racial justice and police accountability in the United States.

In a historic court decision April 20, a Minneapolis jury found former police officer Mr. Derek Chauvin guilty of second-degree murder, third-degree murder, and second-degree manslaughter for his involvement in the high-profile murder of Mr. George Floyd in May 2020, according to The New York Times.  While Mr. Chauvin’s guilty verdict represents an impactful social victory that sets a new standard for police accountability in the United States, it does not ensure long-term justice.  Politicians, activists, and citizens must now turn their attention to addressing underlying systemic issues and pursuing permanent changes in policy.

A group of community artists in Minnesota painted a mural at the site of Mr. Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis, Minnesota to honor Mr. Floyd, other recent victims of police brutality, and protesters advocating for racial justice.  Courtesy of Mr. Jason Armond

Mr. Floyd’s story became a rallying force in the struggle for racial justice.  It sparked the reinvigoration of the Black Lives Matter movement last summer and triggered international demonstrations against police brutality, racial profiling, and discrimination, according to The New York Times.  However, much of the progress that last week’s court decision made now appears ephemeral after the murder of Mr. Duante Wright April 11.  This latest instance of police brutality happened during a traffic stop in Brooklyn Center, Minnesota, approximately ten miles from the courthouse in which the Chauvin trial took place, according to

As demonstrations against the murder of Mr. Wright begin to fill television screens across the nation, it becomes more apparent that the country is trapped in a vicious cycle.  Too often, instances of racially-motivated violence occur, public outcry ensues, and yet government officials fail to pass concrete legislation that would prevent another incident of police brutality.  The death of Mr. Wright, and the numerous other incidents of police violence against communities of color in the past year, reveal that while Mr. Chauvin’s guilty sentence marks a historic victory in the struggle for racial justice, it does not carry the much hoped for immediate impact.

Many Americans regard Mr. Floyd as a symbol for achieving social justice, but the journey towards true progress is far from over.  To ensure true justice for Mr. Floyd, government officials need to pass legislation that guarantees that history will not repeat itself.  This court decision alone cannot provide a concrete solution to the United States’ clear problem with racial inequality and police brutality as it does not bring forth any changes to existing policies.

National politicians and activists are beginning to realize the need for policy change and have vowed to take action.  In a press release April 20, Ms. Cori Bush, United States Congresswoman and advocate for the Black Lives Matter movement, spoke on the importance of achieving true justice for minorities in America.  She detailed her plans to introduce systemic reforms that will benefit her own congressional district in St. Louis, Missouri, as well as the rest of the country.

“We’ve all been forced to grapple with the question: What is justice? Because our criminal-legal system is not a just system—it’s a violent and oppressive one,” Ms. Bush said, according to  “A just world is one where George Floyd is never murdered.  It’s one where Daunte Wright isn’t pulled over for having air fresheners hanging from his rearview mirror.  It’s one where Black lives matter.  These are the same demands we had on the streets of Ferguson.  These are the demands we brought to Congress.  And, together, we will continue working on an ambitious set of policy proposals to transform public safety and to ensure communities like St. Louis no longer live under the constant threat of police violence.”

Ms. Bush is one of the numerous members of Congress who pledged to enact legislative reform.  In a press briefing after the announcement of the court verdict in the Chauvin case, members of Mr. Floyd’s family and lawyers involved in the case called on Congress to pass the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act.  Co-sponsors of this legislation, California Representative Ms. Karen Bass, New York Representative Mr. Jerrold Nadler, New Jersey Senator Mr. Cory Booker, and current Vice President Ms. Kamala Harris, succeeded in passing the bill through the House of Representatives in June 2020, but it failed to clear the Senate.

Without concrete legislative action to combat instances of police violence, history will continue to repeat itself.  Courtesy of Mr. David Delgado

Notable aspects of the bill include a legal requirement for all law enforcement officers to undergo training on discriminatory profiling and a law that only permits officers to use deadly force as a last resort after all alternative deescalation techniques have failed.  The legislation would also enforce federal bans on the use of chokeholds and no-knock warrants in drug cases, as well as a law that enables individuals to sue for civil damages when police officers violate their constitutional rights, according to

 Mr. Benjamin Crump, attorney for the Floyd family, hopes that the high-profile nature of this case will encourage the passage of the bill.  He hopes that, as a result, Mr. Floyd’s death will serve as more than a symbolic victory.

“Justice for Black America is justice for all of America,” Mr. Crump said, according to  “This case is a turning point in American history for accountability of law enforcement and sends a clear message.”

Featured Image by Leah Allen ’22